35+ Reliable Vehicles That Are Surprisingly Underrated
Whenever someone looks for a used car, the Corollas and Civics often steal the spotlight. But they're not the only good vehicles out there. There are plenty of other cars with exceptional reliability and durability that get overshadowed by the same old popular models.
From underrated gems and discontinued cars to the ones that are still going strong, we've got you covered with plenty of reliable used cars that deserve a spot in your garage… and that won’t break the bank. So let’s get started. Keep reading through and comment to let us know what you think.
Buick Verano: 2012-2017
The 2013 Buick Verano boasts an impressive J.D. Power reliability score of 91/100. In addition to that, it has an insulated cabin that effectively mitigates road noise to ensure a serene driving experience, and a remarkable storage capacity for its class with 14.3 cubic feet of cargo space.
Moreover, it's also not short on power, thanks to its standard 180-hp engine that comes with an optional turbocharged variant that ramps up the output to 250 horses. The ride is reasonably comfortable as well.
Chevrolet Volt: 2011-2019
The result of a bold move by GM, the Chevy Volt was a "range-extended electric vehicle" – or what we call a plug-in hybrid today. It can travel 35 miles on electric power alone and has a fuel economy of 35 mpg in the city and 40 mpg on the highway.
In addition to its stellar fuel efficiency, the Volt offers swift acceleration and sharp handling. By Level 2 charging, it takes 4 hours to fully charge, and by using a household 120-volt cable, it takes 10-12 hours to fully top up.
Scion tC: 2004-2016
Produced by Toyota's now-discontinued sub-brand Scion from 2004 to 2016 across two generations, the Scion tC (or "touring coupe”) was the brand's top-selling model, comprising nearly 40% of its total sales.
The Scion tC offered a blend of style and reliability while also garnering praise for its agile handling and roomy back seat. You can get this car for a really affordable price but keep in mind that its fuel efficiency is not as good as many rivals in the category.
Chevrolet Cruze: 2011-2023
The Chevrolet Cruze ensures a comfortable and smooth ride that makes it ideal for both daily commutes and long road trips. The compact car offers a luxurious cabin with effective insulation to minimize road noise disturbances.
For engine options, you can either go for gas or diesel, with diesel models and the Eco trim offering impressive fuel economy. The Cruze also offers a number of great standard features including satellite radio, a CD player, air conditioning, and keyless entry.
Hyundai i20: 2009-present
The Hyundai i20 is a supermini hatchback introduced by the brand in 2008 to replace the Getz. The i20's compact size makes it well-suited for navigating urban environments while providing ample interior space for passengers and cargo.
The hatchback boasts a comfortable and well-appointed interior with supportive seating and intuitive controls. And depending on the trim level and model year, you can get touchscreen infotainment, smartphone integration, automatic climate control, and even keyless entry. It’s also safe and reliable to drive.
Pontiac Vibe: 2003-2010
The Pontiac Vibe was a result of a collaboration between General Motors and Toyota. Derived from the Corolla, the Vibe was a budget-friendly car that was powerful, practical, and reliable (even though Pontiac is not synonymous with reliability).
Unfortunately, the production of the compact hatchback ended with the discontinuation of the Pontiac brand in 2009. Its twin – the Toyota Matrix – however, stayed in production for another 3 years for the US market and 4 years for the Canadian market.
Hyundai Accent: 1995-present
Available in both sedan and hatchback versions, the Hyundai Accent delivers poised handling and a comfortable ride, making it an enjoyable option for daily commuting. The subcompact car surpasses expectations for its price range, thanks to its surprisingly upscale cabin.
The 2013 Accent which has a reliability score of 83/100 from J.D. Power is our favorite. It boasts impressive cargo space, with sedans offering 13.7 cubic feet in the trunk, while hatchback models providing 21.2 cubic feet with all seats in place.
Toyota Aygo: 2006-2023
The Toyota Aygo is known for its compact size, efficient engines, and practicality, which makes it well-suited for urban driving. Launched in 2005, this small city car has since undergone several updates and redesigns, and is available in both three-door and five-door hatchback variants.
Over the years, the Aygo has gained popularity for its affordable sticker price, low running costs, and customizable options. It also comes with a great range of features including touchscreen infotainment systems and advanced safety tech, depending on the trim level.
Chevrolet Sonic: 2011-2020
The Chevrolet Sonic has a striking exterior design, a surprisingly roomy cabin, and lots of trunk space. The 2015 Sonic features a base 138-hp four-cylinder engine as well as a turbo option for those who want more pep.
The Sonic not just has impressive fuel economy, it also surprises with its advanced features. These include a standard Wi-Fi hotspot and available heated front seats, 7-inch touchscreen, Siri Eyes Free, leather upholstery, and remote start.
Ford Focus (Manual): 2000-present
Ford Focus has always been a big name, but its third generation, which debuted for the 2012 model year, gained the most popularity. The 2012 Focus was, in fact, the best-selling car in the world.
Unveiled as part of Alan Mulally's "One Ford" plan, the 2012 Focus debuted with a 2.0-L Ti-VCT 4-cylinder engine, delivering 160 hp. The later model years of the Focus had severe flaws in the PowerShift automatic transmission, so make sure to only buy manual models.
Peugeot 107: 2006-2015
The Peugeot 107 was introduced in 2005 as part of a joint venture between Peugeot, Citroën and Toyota, alongside the Citroën C1 and Toyota Aygo. The 107 shares its platform and many components with the Aygo and the C1.
Like the other two vehicles, the 107 is available in both three-door and five-door hatchback variants, and is known for its fuel efficiency and practicality. Besides packing many great features, the 107's compact size makes it easy to park and maneuver, making it perfect for crowded city streets.
Subaru Legacy: 1990-present
Holding a strong position in affordable midsize cars, the Legacy is a great option for drivers who require enhanced traction in adverse weather conditions since it is the only vehicle in its class that offers all-wheel drive as a standard feature.
Our favorite is the 2013 Legacy, which comes equipped with a standard four-cylinder engine producing 173 horsepower, with an optional upgrade to a more robust 256-horsepower six-cylinder engine. Other standard features include projector-beam headlights and keyless entry.
Mazda 2: 2002-present
Produced and marketed by Mazda since 2002, the Mazda2 is now in its third generation. It is positioned as an entry-level model outside Japan, and sits below the Mazda3 in the brand's lineup.
Even though it was a great car (its second-generation was awarded the 2008 World Car of the Year title), it couldn’t achieve the same level of sales as the Fiesta or Corsa in the US. Nonetheless, the Mazda2 is a great car that offers exciting performance and exceptional handling.
Nissan Leaf: 2011-present
The world's first mass market all-electric vehicle, the Nissan Leaf is currently in its second generation. Despite the brand's reputation for reliability and quality issues compared to other Japanese automakers, this compact hatchback stands out as an exception.
Ever since Consumer Reports unveiled its first review of the Leaf, it has consistently earned a rating of either 4/5 or 5/5 for reliability. But keep in mind that its sluggish acceleration and restricted range will only serve you well in urban environments.
Scion iM: 2016
Taking its platform and engine from the older Toyota Corolla hatchback, the Scion iM – also known as the Auris in Europe and Japan – is a reliable and affordable compact car.
Compared to the Corolla's torsion beam setup, the iM boasts a more sophisticated control-arm rear suspension and is powered by the same 1.8-liter four-cylinder engine that delivers 137 horsepower and 126 pound-feet of torque. The iM comes standard with a six-speed manual transmission, but a CVT is also available.
Kia Forte: 2009-present
Available in two-door coupe, four-door sedan, and five-door hatchback variants, the Kia Forte has been a popular vehicle ever since its launch in 2008. With the exception of the coupe, the Forte offers ample head- and legroom in both rows. It also boasts stellar cargo capacity behind the seats.
Kia ensures that the small car is well-equipped with a range of standard features, including Bluetooth connectivity and satellite radio. It is also a reliable car, with a consistent 80+ score in J.D. Power reliability ratings.
Honda Fit: 2002-present
The Honda Fit has always been a practical and fun-to-drive hatchback, with impressive reliability scores. It also boasts a spacious and flexible cargo area to let you accommodate items of various shapes and sizes. In addition to that, both rows of seats provide comfortable seating for adults.
Our favorite is the 2013 Fit that you can easily get under $10,000. Its 117-hp four-cylinder engine may lack highway prowess, but its lively handling more than makes up for that. The 2013 Fit also has a J.D. Power reliability score of 85/100.
Scion iA: 2016
Essentially a rebranded Mazda2, the Scion iA inherited stellar reliability, excellent handling, and remarkable fuel economy without the hefty price tag associated with the Mazda badge.
The subcompact car also had impressive safety scores and a really upscale cabin (for the price), all of which helped it rank in the top of its category in the year it was launched. But since the car was sold for just one year, its price has been surging due to limited supply.
Toyota Auris: 2006-2019
The Toyota Auris is a compact hatchback introduced in 2006 as a replacement for the Toyota Corolla hatchback in Europe. The Auris was designed to offer a more modern and dynamic alternative to its predecessor.
Since it is derived from the Corolla, the Auris is understandably a practical, reliable, versatile, and efficient vehicle that is perfect for everyday use. And as with other Toyota models, it is reliable and dependable as well, that makes it an ideal family hauler.
Kia Ceed: 2007-present
Introduced in 2006 as Kia's entry into the highly competitive compact hatchback segment in Europe, the name Ceed stands for "Community of Europe, with European Design."
Offering a combination of style, comfort, and value for money, the Ceed is available in multiple body styles and engine options to allow buyers to choose a model that best suits their needs. Kia has also equipped the Ceed with a range of safety features, including multiple airbags, stability control, anti-lock brakes, and a comprehensive driver assistance suite.
Nissan Versa: 2006-present
Prioritizing spaciousness over everything else, the Nissan Versa offers remarkable space for both passengers and cargo. The name of the vehicle is, in fact, derived from "versatile space".
The Versa's cabin may feel a bit cheap, and its CVT can be noisy under hard acceleration… but don’t forget that it’s one of the most affordable vehicles on the market. All in all, it’s a comfortable, reliable and practical car that fulfills all requirements of a family vehicle meant for city use… without breaking the bank.
Hyundai Sonata: 1986-present
The Hyundai Sonata is not just renowned for its outstanding reliability, it also boasts impressive safety scores and stands out as one of the most fuel-efficient midsize sedans available.
Our favorite is the 2013 iteration that comes with a 198-hp four-cylinder engine as standard. For those seeking more potency, a turbocharged four-cylinder option, generating a robust 274 hp, is also available. The 2013 Sonata also comes with Bluetooth connectivity, dual-zone automatic climate control, and a number of standard features to enhance your driving experience.
Nissan Sentra: 1983-present
The Nissan Sentra stands out for its impressively spacious cabin, which is a rare find in the subcompact sedan segment. The front-row headroom may be limited for taller drivers though, particularly in models equipped with a sunroof.
As for powertrain, the Sentra packs sufficient power for everyday driving needs. And while standard features may be basic, optional amenities include Bluetooth, satellite radio, navigation, and push-button start, adding a lot of convenience to your commute. It also scores well in J.D. Power reliability ratings.
Kia Soul: 2009-present
Boasting one of the most spacious cabins in its class, the Kia Soul not just has ample head and legroom, it also has a generous cargo area behind the rear seats. Moreover, the subcompact crossover SUV offers precise steering and a comfortable ride to ensure an enjoyable driving experience.
The Soul is also renowned for its exceptional value and extensive list of standard features… that include but are not limited to Bluetooth connectivity, satellite radio, and steering wheel-mounted audio controls. It’s also highly reliable!
Chevrolet Malibu: 1997–present
The Chevy Malibu is an attractive option for those seeking an affordable used midsize sedan. Our favorite is the 2013 iteration that earns a commendable reliability score of 84/100 from J.D. Power.
The base model is equipped with a 197-hp engine, while for those desiring more power, Chevy offers a turbocharged four-cylinder option boasting 259 horses. The cabin is stylish and the higher trims offer push-button start, leather upholstery, dual-zone climate control, and heated front seats.
Kia Rio: 2001-2023
Available as three and five-door hatchback and four-door sedan, the Kia Rio is a stylish subcompact perfect for family use. Our top pick is the 2015 model that garnered a remarkable score of 87/100 in J.D. Power reliability ratings.
Under the hood, the 2015 Rio packs a 138-hp four-cylinder engine and a number of standard features including satellite radio, a CD player, a USB port, and a four-speaker audio system. If you want a more upscale cabin, the higher trims offer just that.
Mazda Mazda6: 2002-present
While the Mazda3 often steals the spotlight due to its rivalry with the Civic and the Corolla, the Mazda6 (known as the Mazda Atenza in Japan) tends to get overlooked by a wide majority of buyers.
Slightly beefier and more upscale than its little sibling, the Mazda6 perfectly embodies the brand's "Stylish, Insightful and Spirited" design ethos. Being one of the most fun to drive cars on the market, Car and Driver has consistently named it as an Editor's Choice every year since 2017.
Volkswagen Jetta TDI (Diesel): 1980-present
Spanning over seven generations, the VW Jetta occupies a sedan spot above the Golf hatchback. The Jetta TDI features a 2.0-L turbo diesel engine renowned for its impressive torque output and exceptional highway mileage.
The vehicle's (and the brand’s) reputation was tarnished when U.S. regulators found that Volkswagen had equipped hundreds of thousands of its diesel vehicles with a "defeat device" to evade environmental regulations. So if you want to buy it, opt for a model retrofitted with Volkswagen's emissions fix (this can be verified using VW's modification search tool).
Suzuki Alto: 1979-present
The Suzuki Alto is a very small hatch with a severely underpowered three-cylinder engine, a cheaply-built bland interior, and practically non-existent safety features. But it has its upsides as well…
The Alto is known for its super-compact size, stellar fuel efficiency, and insane affordability. It is popular in various markets around the world, especially in regions where smaller, more economical vehicles are favored. All in all, it can reliably haul you from A to B in an extremely cost-effective manner.
Volkswagen Golf TDI (Diesel): 1974-present
With over 35 million units sold since 1974, the Volkswagen Golf has been marketed worldwide in numerous trim levels and powertrain options, making it one of the most popular vehicles ever.
Like the Jetta TDI, the Golf TDI too delivers a commendable mix of performance and fuel efficiency, but was marred by the same diesel scandal. So before buying, do make sure your model has been retrofitted with VW’s emissions fix through the brand’s modification search.
Mazda MX-5: 1990-present
The Mazda MX-5, aka the Mazda Miata, is a two-seat sports car and a true automotive icon. Introduced in 1989 with the aim of reviving the classic lightweight, front-engine, rear-wheel-drive sports car concept, it quickly gained popularity for its fun-to-drive nature, affordability, and reliability.
Over the years, the MX-5 has garnered a strong following worldwide and has become one of the best-selling two-seat convertible sports cars in history. If you want a vehicle with engaging driving dynamics and nimble handling, look no more.
Toyota Corolla: 1966-present
Any model of Corolla is a great buy, but if you want the best combo of affordability and features, you can consider buying the 2012 model. Its 1.8-L, 132-hp, four-cylinder engine offers decent performance alongside excellent fuel efficiency, averaging 32 mpg in mixed driving.
And even though the vehicle lacks engagement, it handles well and provides a refined driving experience. The steering feels light and the suspension effectively absorbs bumps, providing a smooth and controlled ride on the highway. Additionally, you have a quiet interior and a spacious rear seat.
Hyundai Elantra: 1990-present
The Hyundai Elantra stands out as a well-rounded, affordable, and reliable subcompact car. Our favorite pick is the 2013 iteration that features a robust 148-hp four-cylinder engine.
While it may not excel in any single aspect, it offers a good cabin space for its size, an above-average trunk space of 14.8 cubic feet, and a pretty decent interior. The trims with auto transmission feature an Active Eco Fuel system that enhances fuel economy, delivering 28 mpg in the city and 38 mpg on the highway.
Honda Accord: 1976-present
All Accords are worth buying but the 2012 iteration stands out with its perfect blend of affordability and reliability. It has a spacious cabin, enjoyable driving experience, and lots of trunk space. And despite being the last model year before a redesign, it has a pretty handsome appearance as well.
While the base 4-cylinder engine may feel underpowered in certain situations, you also have the option to get the more energetic V6 engine. Both engine options are available with either an automatic or manual transmission.
Mazda Mazda3: 2003-present
If you think you need to break the bank for a dynamic driving experience, the Mazda3 is here to prove you wrong. You can easily get the 2013 model for under $10k and enjoy a refined ride with remarkably sharp handling.
The 2013 Mazda3 produces 148 horses with its base engine and a remarkable 263 horses with its turbocharged engine. It's available in both sedan and hatchback body styles, with the hatchback model including push-button start, dual-zone automatic climate control, and Bluetooth connectivity to enhance your riding comfort.
Nissan Altima: 1992–present
Known for its well-built interior and balanced ride, the Altima offers versatility with its sedan and coupe variants. Our favorite – the 2012 Altima – comes equipped with a 170-hp four-cylinder engine as standard. For quicker acceleration, the upgraded V6 engine produces 270 horses.
While the rear seats may feel cramped in the coupe, the front seats offer ample space and comfort. The higher trim levels include luxurious amenities such as a 6.5-inch navigation screen, dual-zone automatic climate control, heated front seats, and leather upholstery.
Toyota Camry: 1982-present
The Toyota Camry features a quiet cabin, excellent reliability, and top-notch safety scores. Our favorite – the 2013 model – has a number of great standard features including a user-friendly infotainment system.
Even though the base engine is more than suitable for city driving, you can also opt for the 268-hp V6 for more pep. The 2013 Camry also offers ample storage capacity compared to its competitors… with a trunk space of 15.3 cubic feet. All in all, it's a great car worth every penny.
Chevrolet Camaro: 2010–2024
The Chevy Camaro is one of the most iconic cars ever made, that's for sure… but there’s something special about the 2010 Camaro that we can’t get over with.
Making a comeback with a sleek design, the 2010 Camaro was made available with either a V6 or V8 engine, both offering a lively performance along with good fuel economy (for a sports car). The best thing is, its ride quality and suspension ensured both agility in corners as well as comfort on long routes.
Honda Civic: 1972-present
Renowned for its exceptional reliability and remarkable safety, every Civic is worth buying… that's for sure. But, the 2012 model is our favorite because it provides an insane value for money. It not just delivers a thrilling ride, but also ensures an impressive fuel economy.
The compact sedan received a full redesign for the 2012 model year (that continued through 2015). The base trim was equipped with a 140-hp engine, while the Si trim (meant for those seeking more power) came with a 201-hp engine. Whatever trim you get is a good purchase!
Lexus CT200h: 2011-2022
A luxury hybrid based on the Toyota Prius drivetrain and Toyota MC platform, the Lexus CT200h is equipped with a 1.8-liter VVT-i four-cylinder petrol engine complemented by an electric motor to produce 134 hp and 153 lbf-ft of torque.
The CT200h offers a blend of reliability and fuel efficiency. It also has an upscale interior and ample cargo space. Thanks to its relatively unknown name, you can get a good deal in the used car market.
Read More: Drool-Worthy Photos Of The Most Iconic Hot Rods Ever Made
